home > plop > 2006 > Papers > Notes > 24-notes.php

PLoP 2006 Shepherded Papers

Notes on Paper 24:

I was waiting for the shepherds comments to add my PC remarks to it, but I think this paper must have
been the one that Joe Bergin referred to as being OK.

I make a clear recommendation to accept the paper "Pedagogical Patterns from the Teachlet Laboratory" for a PLoP workshop.

The paper is well written, the author knows his material, the patterns fit well with the overall work on pedagogical patterns,
the format is good, and the patterns are mature (good P-S pairs, good forces, good resulting context/considerations section).
All together a paper that is short, useful and enjoyable to read.

The shepherding process went fine, good comments, paper improved during the shepherding, the author was responsive and
was thrilled to have Joe as his shepherd (no surprise...).

Cheers,
Lise