home > plop > 2006 > Papers > Notes > 32-notes.php

PLoP 2006 Shepherded Papers

Notes on Paper 32:

My recommendation: Accept the paper.

Initially, I was a bit concerned about the state of the paper. 1)
It was too long for the workshop and 2) Many parts of the paper
were incomplete.

We agreed on a limited scope.

The authors have done substantial amount of work to make the paper
look more complete and polished. Right now, there is only one
pattern which is incomplete (the Interest Agent pattern). The
authors will either remove it from the final version or complete
writing the pattern.

I thought that the patterns were interesting and useful. These
patterns are a subset of a larger pattern language for distributed
collaboration, and the authors have a good knowledge of the big picture.

I think this will be an interesting paper to read and discuss in PLoP
2006.

Munawar