home > plop > 2006 > Papers > Notes > 50-notes.php

PLoP 2006 Shepherded Papers

Notes on Paper 4

Comments for Paper #050--enclosed PDF
I suggest this paper is accepted for a special venue at PLoP for the
research style papers. Maybe have a presentation done that is
recorded and a workshop giving feedback to both the paper and
presentation at the same time.

I liked the concept and the paper flowed well and was easy to
read. It was a nice format, well laid out, and good use of diagrams,
fonts, sections and the like.

The motivation was a little weak and I couldn't completely see the
why of the paper. They need to convince me a bit more but they did
work well with shepherding and I think both PLoP and the authors will
benefit by the acceptance of this paper.

--joe